ISSN: 2167-0420
Review Article - (2021)
Background: There is increasing use of fertility drugs for ovulation induction and ovarian stimulation in assisted reproductive treatment like In Vitro Fertilization. For the treatment of subfertility, several medications are used to grow more eggs these drugs used to stimulate their ovaries may fuel cancer risk. In this review, recent literature regarding the correlation between fertility drug and cancer risk is reviewed to find out whether the medicines used to stimulate ovulation increase the risk of any gynecological cancer in women.
Main body: Broad controversy exists in the literature about fertility treatment-induced cancer, although clinical trials are generally more focused. In order to present comprehensive strategies, the author has attempted to synthesize findings from Forty-seven research papers. The purpose of this study is to present a systematic review of the available evidence-based research paper concerning the relationship between fertility drug and gynecological cancers.
Conclusion: The result of this study shows support for the correlation between fertility drugs and certain cancer risk, the correlation should continue to be monitored because the included studies had several limitations and multiple differences in the way they were conducted. However, we suggest the need to counsel women about their potential risk of Uterine/ Endometrial cancer and Breast Cancer in the future before any treatment procedure.
WHO: World Health Organization; IVF: In Vitro Fertilization; CC: Clomiphene Citrate; HMG: Human Menopausal Gonadotropin; FSH: Follicle Stimulating Hormone; HCG: Human Chorionic Gonadotropin; ART: Artificial Reproduction Technology; IRR: Individual Research Result; OI: Ovulation Induction.
Reproductive health is a priority global health area, According to WHO One in every four couples in developing nations had been seen as influenced by infertility. The rate of primary female infertility is ranged from 1.9 to 2.6% and secondary female infertility ranged from 7.3 to 17% with the highest rates in Central and Eastern Europe, followed by South Asia at 12.2% and Sub-Saharan Africa. This data consolidated information between 1990 and 2010, providing a 5-year projection of infertility [1]. According to this data, the highest rates of infertility were concentrated through Africa and Central/Eastern Europe [2]. Simi et al. explored the significance of early detection of female infertility in [3-5]. World Health Organization ICD-11 describes female infertility as a Disease of the reproductive system defined by the failure to achieve a clinical pregnancy after 12 months or more of regular unprotected sexual intercourse [6]. All clinical studies will begin after at least one year according to the World Health Organization (WHO).
In recent years, an incredible interest has been arisen to find the correlation between infertility treatments and cancer development, mainly breast, uterus, and ovarian cancer [7]. The importance of understanding any existing correlation between fertility medications and cancer risk is crucial because the use of these treatments has become very common, with approximately 1 million in vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles reported per year worldwide furthermore to an obscure number of ovulation induction cycles. This paper evaluates the association of fertility drugs and gynecological cancer risk [8,9].
Ovulation-inducing agents have been broadly used to treat infertility issues, either alone such as anti-estrogens (e.g. clomiphene citrate [CC] ), or as part of IVF cycles including human menopausal gonadotropin (hMG), follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), and human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG). Infertile women with normal ovulatory function, who have been exposed to excessive CC and/or gonadotropin administration, continually raised estrogen and progestogen concentrations, and numerous ovulatory cycles may be more prone to changes in the ovarian tissue than those with ovulatory disorders. This review systematically analyzes the 47 most significant research papers published on this topic to summarize the correlation between infertility drugs and gynecological cancers.
This study aimed to create a comprehensive picture of the association between infertility drug and the risk of ovarian, endometrial, cervical, and breast cancer in women. The highlight of this paper was we only concentrate on cohort or case-control study of large population and single cancer researches [10].
This paper presented a review of the scientific literature concerning the relationship between the use of fertility drugs and the risk of gynecological cancers. We searched digital databases including Pubmed, MEDLINE, and Google. The survey was completed using keywords such as "infertility", "ovarian stimulation consequences", " ovarian cancer risk", "gynecological cancer and fertility drug", "gynecological cancer risk", " Endometrial Cancer", "fertility drugs", "infertility treatment and cancer risk", variously associated together (Table 1). The criteria for entering the study included either case-control or cohort study. Initially 84 articles were selected by checking the keywords. The fertility drug used is In vitro fertilization (IVF) Procedure and clomiphene citrate, the gonadotropins, human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), and human menopausal gonadotropin (hMG), alone or in combination. 46 were selected for the research paper based on relevance and clear findings. Figure 1 shows the flowchart of the inclusion methodology.
Reference & Year | Country | Study Duration | Study Population | Study Design | Medication | Research Finding(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trabert et al [4] -2013 | United States | 1965-88 with follow-up through 2010 |
9825 | Cohort | Clomiphene citrate gonadotropins | No correlation between fertility drugs and ovarian cancer risk. Overweight is associated with Ovarian cancer risk However, their study suggests that Use of fertility drug and failure to attain pregnancy was related to ovarian cancer risk |
Modan et al [5]-1998 | Israel | 1964- 1974 |
2496 | Cohort | Clomiphene citrate hMG |
suggest that treatment with ovulation- inducing drugs doesn't increase the risk for ovarian cancer |
Bjørnholt et al [6]- 2015 | Denmar k | 1963- 2006 |
96545 | Cohort | Gonadotrophi ns clomiphene citrate human chorionic gonadotrophin s |
No correlation between fertility drugs and ovarian cancer risk. But they observed an increased risk for serious borderline ovarian tumors after the use of progesterone. |
Stewart et al [7] -2013 | Australi a | 1982- 2002 |
21646 | Cohort | IVF | No Evidence for ovarian cancer growth following IVF in women who conceive an offspring. Meanwhile unsuccessful women have some risk. |
Sanner et al. [8]-2009 | Sweden | 1961-75 | 2768 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate gonadotropins | An increased risk of ovarian cancer gonadotropins and borderline tumors after clomiphene treatment. |
Franceschi et al [9] 1994 | Italy | Since 1992 | 195 cases 1339 controls |
Case- Control | gonadotropins | No association between ovulation stimulation drugs and cancer risk. |
Asante et al [10]- 2013 | USA | 1999- 2012 |
1900 cases- 1028 control- 872 |
Case- control | gonadotropins | No Correlation between fertility drug use and risk of ovarian tumors |
Kurta et al [11] 2012 | USA | 2003- 2008 |
902 cases Controls, N=1802 | Case- control | clomiphene citrate follicle- stimulating |
No Correlation between fertility drug use and risk of ovarian Tumors |
hormone (FSH), human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), gonadotropin, and human menopausal gonadotropin (hMG) |
||||||
Leeuwen et al [12]- 2011 | Netherla nds | 1983- 1995 |
19146 | Cohort | IVF | Ovarian stimulation for IVF may increase the risk of borderline ovarian tumors |
Rizzuto et al [13]- 2019 |
1990- 2013 |
4,684,724 | Cohort and Case- control | IVF | Infertility drugs may increase the risk of ovarian cancer slightly in subfertile women treated with infertility drugs. |
|
Brinton et al [22]- 2004 |
1965-88 | 12,193 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate gonadotropins | No Correlation between fertility drug use and risk of ovarian tumors | |
Parazzini et al [24]- 2001 |
Italy | 1992-99 | Cases 1031 Controls 2411 |
Case- control | no information was available | Observed a moderate association between fertility drugs and ovarian cancer risk |
Vassard et al. [39]- 2019 |
Denmar k | 1994- 2015 |
Cases 58472 Controls 625330 |
Case- control | IVF | Observed an association between ART treatment and the risk of ovarian cancer among women with endometriosis |
Lundberg et al. [47]- 2019 |
Sweden | women born 1942â?? 1992 |
2,882,847 | Cohort | Not specified | Ovarian cancer incidence was higher in women diagnosed with endometriosis |
Williams CL et al. [52] -2018 | Great Britain | 1991- 2010 |
255â??786 | Cohort | ART | Increased risks of invasive and borderline ovarian cancer were found |
Table 1: Study of Fertility drug effect and ovarian cancer.
Figure 1: Flow chart demonstrating methodology of articles searched, filtered & included.
No study design restrictions and periods have been applied in this research. A general concern is that the medication of infertility has changed over the years. Specific fertility drugs that are currently in the commonplace, such as gonadotropins, were not broadly used until the late 1980s. Therefore, a few studies might not have caught exposure to this study. Furthermore, Cohort studies also have inherent advantages and limitations because in most of the studies data are collected via interview or answering the questionnaires, numerous cohort studies are restricted by an absence of long-term follow-up, prompting lower apparent occurrence of disease as cancers may occur many years after the medications. Reference lists of the most significant papers were likewise analyzed and examined the full versions of all relevant studies. The strength of this study includes the large size of the cohort and the long and complete follow-up, providing sufficient power for subgroup analyses (Tables 2-4) [11-13].
Reference &Year | Country | Study Duration | Study Population | Study Design | Medication | Research Finding(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Modan et al. [5]- 1998 |
Israel | 1964- 1974 |
2496 | Cohort | Clomiphene citrate hMG |
suggested that the chance of association between infertility drug and the development of endometrial cancer can't be avoided |
Reigstad et al. [14]- 2017 |
Norway | 2004- 2014 |
1,353,724 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate and ART exposure |
Clomiphene citrate appears associated with an increased risk of Endometrial cancer. |
Jensen et al. [15]- 2009 |
Denmar k | 1965- 1998 |
54,362 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate gonadotropi ns human chorionic gonadotropin |
Correlation between fertility drug (clomiphene citrate, human chorionic gonadotropin) and the risk of uterine cancer was observed. (Exception-: gonadotropin was not associated with risk) |
Althuis et al [16]- 2005 |
USA | 1965- 1988 |
8,431 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate | The association between clomiphene use and uterine cancer was observed |
Kessous et al [17]- 2016 |
1988- 2013 |
106,031 | Cohort | IVF and ovulation induction (OI) |
Observed an association between IVF history and uterine cancer | |
Brinton et al. [18]-2013 |
USA | 1965-88 | 12 193 | Cohort | Clomiphene gonadotropi ns | No association between fertility drugs and endometrial cancer risk |
Venn et al. [21]- 2001 |
Australi a | 29,700 | Cohort | IVF | Observed an increased incidence of uterine cancer in women with a history of infertility |
|
Sponholt z et al. [20]- 2017 |
USA | 1995- 2013 |
47,555 | Cohort | IUI | Observed an association between endometrial cancer and fertility drug |
Parazzini et al. [23]- 2010 |
Italy | 1992- 2006 |
454 cases 908 Controls |
case- control | Clomiphene gonadotropi ns | Observed an increase in the risk of endometrial cancer with the duration of fertility drug usage. |
Benshush an et al. [25]- 2001 |
Israel | 1989- 1992 |
128 cases 255 controls |
case- control | clomiphene citrate | No evidence found for proving the association of ovulation-inducing agents, including clomiphene citrate and a higher risk of endometrial cancer. |
Silva et al [54]- 2009 |
British | 20 years | 7355 | Cohort | clomiphene | Women consuming >or=2250mg of clomiphene having a 2.6- fold increase in the risk of Uterine cancer |
Table 2: Study of Fertility drugs effect and Uterine /endometrial cancer.
Reference &Year | Country | Study Duration | Study Population | Study Design | Medication | Research Finding(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Modan et al [5]- 1998 |
Israel | 1964- 1974 |
2496 | Cohort | Clomiphene citrate Hmg |
suggest that treatment with ovulation-inducing drugs doesn't increase the risk for breast cancer |
Brinton et al. [19]- 2014 |
USA | 1989- 2010 |
9,892 | Cohort | Clomiphene gonadotropin s |
Observed an association between gonadotropins and breast cancer risk among nulligravid women |
Burkman et al. [26]- 2003 |
USA | 1994- 1998 |
4,575 case 4,682 control |
case- control |
human menopausal gonadotropin (hMG) clomiphene citrate |
Observed an adverse effect of fertility drug on the risk of breast cancer |
Gauthier et al. [27]- 2004 |
Europe | 1990- 1991 |
98997 | Cohort | Clomid(CC), Ondogyne Neopergonal, menotropin, gonadotropin, chorionic gonadotropin |
Fertility drug does not influence breast cancer risk overall |
Geva et al. [28]- 2006 |
Israel | 1964- 1984 |
120,895 | Cohort and nested case-control study. |
clomiphene citrate, gonadotropin s |
Observed a Significant Risk of breast cancer for women treated with clomiphene citrate |
Jensen et al. [29]- 2007 |
Denmar k |
54,362 | Cohort | gonadotrophins, clomiphene, human chorionic gonadotrophin |
No strong association between breast cancer risk and use of fertility drugs |
|
Pappo et al. [30]- 2008 |
Israel | 1986- 2003 |
3,375 | Cohort | IVF | Observed an association between IVF therapy and breast cancer development |
Orgeas et al. [31]- 2009 |
Sweden | 1961- 1976 |
1135 | Cohort | clomiphene citrate gonadotropin s |
Observed that high-dose clomiphene citrate therapy may have an elevated risk for breast cancer |
Stewart et al. [51]- 2012 |
Australi a |
1983- 2002 |
21,025 | Cohort | IVF | Observed that Commencing IVF treatment at a young age is associated with an increased rate of breast cancer. |
Ricci et al. [32]- 1999 |
Italy | 1983- 1991 |
3 415 cases 2916 controls |
case- control | Not specified | No association between fertility drug treatment and breast cancer risk. |
Krul et al. [33]- 2015 |
Netherla nds | 1983-95 | 12,589 | Cohort | IVF | Observed an association between IVF therapy and breast cancer development |
Reigstad et al. [34]- 2015 |
Norway | 1984- 2010 |
808,834 | Cohort | IVF | Observed an association between IVF therapy and breast cancer development |
Van den et al. [35]- 2016 |
Netherla nds | 1983- 1995 |
19,158 | Cohort | IVF | No association between fertility drug treatment and breast cancer risk. |
Cooley et al. [36]-2012 |
USA | MCF- 10A, MCF-7 and HCC 1937 cell lines |
cell lines | hCG, estrogen, progesterone and clomiphene citrate |
Observed minimal direct effects of infertility treatment on breast cell multiplication | |
Bernstein et al. [37]- 1995 |
USA | 1983- 1988 |
744 case- control pair | case- control | human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) | Observed that hCG may be a means for reducing breast cancer risk. |
Katz et al. [38] | Israel | 1984- 2002 |
7162 | Case- Control | IVF | Observed that Women who start IVF after the age of 30 appear to be at increased risk of developing breast cancer |
Table 3: Study of Fertility drugs effect and breast cancer.
Reference & Year | Country | Study Duration | Population | Study Design | Medication | Research Finding(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kallen et al. [40] | Sweden | 1982- 2006 |
Case:24,058 Control: 1,394,061 |
Case- Control | IVF | Observed a lower risk for cervical cancer in IVF recipients |
Kristiansson et al. [41] |
Sweden | 1981- 2001 |
Case: 8,716 Control: 64,0059 |
Cohort | IVF | Decreased incidence of cervical cancer after IVF treatment |
Dor et al. [42] | Israel | 1981-92 | Total:5,026 | Cohort | Clomiphen e citrate hMG GnRH |
No association between fertility treatment and cervical cancer risk |
Calderon- Margalit et al. [43] | Israel | 1974â?? 2004 |
14463 | Cohort | Clomiphen e citrate | No association between fertility drugs and cervical cancer risk |
Siristatidis et al. [44] | Meta- Analysis | 1966- 2012 |
109 969 | Cohort | IVF | No association between fertility drugs and cervical cancer risk |
Table 4: Study of Fertility drugs effect and Cervical Cancer.
For decades, researchers are trying to discovering the uncovered causes of cancer and the means of prevention. All the gynecological cancers are dangerous especially breast cancer has been the most common life-threatening cancers among women worldwide [14,15]. Infertility has long been perceived as a risk factor for different cancers, including breast, ovary, and
Gynecologic cancers. More recently, concern has been raised for the impacts of medications used to treat infertility, especially since these fertility drugs stimulate ovulation and raise different Hormone levels. Researchers worldwide have been involved with several pieces of research to clarify the effects of fertility drug exposures on the risk of various gynecologic cancers [16].
Analysis of Ovarian Cancer Studies
The Correlation between fertility drugs including those associated with in vitro fertilization (IVF) and cancers is an ongoing concern of both health providers and patients. Gynecological cancers are related to several hormonal and reproductive risk factors. The association among PCOS and endometrial cancer, as well as between endometriosis and ovarian cancer, are genuinely well defined [17-20].
In several years, researchers have investigated the association between borderline ovarian tumors and fertility drugs. Ovarian cancer is rare and the most deadly gynecological cancer worldwide [21-23]. Many pieces of research have shown that an increased risk of ovarian cancer is related to the intake of clomiphene citrate and gonadotropin [24].
Trabert et al. [4] reported that there is a correlation between Clomiphene citrate, gonadotropins, and ovarian cancer risk. They are also able to find Overweight is associated with ovarian cancer risk significantly. However, their study suggests that Use of fertility drugs and failure to attain pregnancy was related to ovarian cancer risk. A 1998 study by Modan et al. [5] suggested that fertility drug doesn’t increase the risk of cancer. Additionally another study by Bjørnholt et al. [6] provided the same result. Stewart et al. [7] concluded that there is no proof of an expanded danger of ovarian cancer growth following IVF in women who conceive an offspring. There is some vulnerability concerning the impact of IVF in ladies who remain nulliparous they have an increased chance of Risk.
Although some studies have shown an increased risk [25-28], most studies do not show an overall increase of ovarian cancer in women exposed to fertility drugs [28]. However, some suggest a possible increased risk within subgroups, including sub fertile women, and women who are not conceived even after the medication. Reviewing the recently documented literature [29-31], demonstrate a significantly increased risk of invasive and borderline ovarian cancer. Two studies suggested an increased risk of ovarian cancer associated with endometriosis [32,33].
Analysis of Uterine /Endometrial Cancer Studies
Endometrial cancer is one of the hormone-related cancers. Death rates for uterine cancer began to increase around 2000 in the wake of increasing occurrence rates. According to the recent statistics, excess weight increases endometrial cancer risk by 50%. The results of several cohort studies showed an increase in uterine cancer among women who used ovulation-inducing drugs [31-35]. In this study, we have selected 11 relevant types of research. Out of 11 nine studies shown a Correlation between fertility drugs and the risk of uterine/endometrial cancer.
Reviewing the literature yields suggested that the chance of association between infertility drugs and the development of endometrial cancer can't be avoided [36]. According to a cohort of 1,353,724 women, the incidence of endometrial cancer increases in women who have a history of clomiphene citrate drug usage more than 6 cycles. A cohort study that lasted for 33-years revealed that uterine cancer is associated with the usage of clomiphene citrate and one exception point they reported is gonadotropin was not associated with risk [15]. This is consistent with the finding of Althuis's study. Kessous et al. [37] have attempted to pursue the conclusion that, an association between IVF history and uterine cancer are existing. In a retrospective study, Sponholtz et al [20] communicate that fruitful women were less likely to develop endometrial cancer (IRR 0.77, 95% CI 0.57, 1.05) than nulliparous women.
A study by Venn et al. [21] the incidence of uterine cancer increases in women who have a history of infertility. The results of a case-control study stated the duration of the use of fertility drugs was positively associated with endometrial cancer risk. There have been a few studies that did not show any association between fertility drugs including clomiphene citrate and a higher risk of endometrial cancer [38-40]. A 20 years British cohort study of 7355 women concluded that consumption of more than 2,250 mg of clomiphene is associated with a 2.6-fold increase in the risk of uterus cancers relative to those who were not treated.
Analysis of Breast Cancer Studies
Breast cancer is the leading cause of cancer death in women aged 20 to 59 years [41-43]. From 2005 to 2014, in general, breast cancer incidence rates expanded. Although the relationship between breast cancer and ovulation-inducing drugs is not clear, it appears that these drugs increase breast cell multiplication. Some studies reported that breast cancer diagnosed within the initial 2 years following infertility treatment is similar in cancer characteristics compared with those happening in patients without earlier fruitlessness treatment [45,45].
Most recent studies have shown an association between the risk of breast cancer and fertility drug usage when comparing women undergoing fertility treatment [46-48]. Although few recent studies found no association of fertility drugs with breast cancer risk. Treatment with ovulation-inducing drugs is not associated with an increased risk of a breast cancer diagnosis is the conclusion of one early study. The use of gonadotropins, due to ovulation disorders, increases breast cancer risk among nulliparous women [49]. A case-control study of 4,575 cases and 4,862 controls aged between 35 to 64 found that extensive use of fertility drugs could initiate some negative effect; the relative risk of breast cancer in women with an hMG use for more than 6 months was between 207 to 3.8.
The author of this cohort study provided the information that there is no evidence of an association between fertility drug and breast cancer risk but a family history of cancer can affect. An Israelian study on the effect of ovulation-inducing drugs discloses that for barren ladies treated with clomiphene citrate, breast cancer risk is elevated. They have adopted a cohort and nested case-control study of 20 years to reach into this conclusion. A Danish cohort study of 54,362 women with infertility problems, however, did show no strong association between breast cancer and ovulation-inducing fertility drugs, but they suggested a long term follow up of among nulliparous women exposed to gonadotropin, this suggestion support the result of Brinton et al. [19].
Some previous studies have also revealed an increased risk of breast cancer in women who used fertility drugs [50,51]. Orgeas et al. [31] convey that cancer risk is associated with high-dose clomiphene citrate for women treated with nonovulatory causes. An IVF cohort study of women aged 20-44 years reported that risk of breast cancer was associated with women they had their first delivery at a late age (HR=1.56,95% CI 1.01-2.40) [51]. A breast cell proliferation study supported minimal direct effects of infertility treatment on breast cell multiplication.
The result of a registry-based cohort study of 808,834 women showed that the risk of breast cancer increased in individuals who gave birth following IVF [95 % CI 1.07-1.71] [34]. These data agree with a recent 2 IVF cohort studies comprised of 12589 women [52]. A 12-year long cohort study of 19,158 IVF treated women revealed that the risk of breast cancer in IVF-treated women was not significantly different from that in the general population and from the risk in the non-IVF group. The result of a case-control study of 18 years showed that an increased risk of breast cancer was associated with women who undergo IVF treatment after the age of 30 years [38]. Meanwhile, many researchers could not show a positive relationship between fertility treatment and breast cancer.
Analysis of Cervical Cancer studies
A few studies assessing the risk of cervical cancer following fertility treatment have consistently shown no increased risk of cervical cancer compared to both the general population and infertile women as controls. A subset of studies has discovered a decreased incidence of cervical cancer in IVF patients, although the mechanism behind this phenomenon is unclear but perhaps related to better access to care with more frequent cervical cytology screening in women experiencing fertility medication. Twenty four years of case-control study disclose that they can find a lower risk of cervical cancer in IVF treated women [40]. A cohort study of Swedish women showed that IVF treated women had a decreased rate of cervical cancer [41]. Overall the results of the present study suggest that fertility drug is not a risk factor for cervical cancer [53-57].
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable
Consent for publication
Not applicable
Availability of Data and Material
Not applicable
Competing Interests
Not applicable
Funding
Not applicable
Authors' Contributions
MS analyzed and interpreted the 47 research data regarding the correlation between fertility treatment and Gynecological cancers.
Acknowledgements
Not applicable
Citation: Simi MS (2021). Correlation between Fertility Drug and the Likelihood of Gynecological Cancer - A Systematic Review. J Women's Health Care 10:548. doi: 10.35248/2167-0420.21.10.548.
Received: 06-Aug-2021 Accepted: 23-Aug-2021 Published: 30-Aug-2021
Copyright: © 2021 Simi MS. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.