International Journal of Advancements in Technology

International Journal of Advancements in Technology
Open Access

ISSN: 0976-4860

+44 1478 350008

Original Article - (2018) Volume 9, Issue 4

Development and Performance Evaluation of a Novel Fire Detection and Extinguishing System: Towards Industrial Automation

Md. Selim Reza1* and SM Mamun2
1Department of Natural Sciences, BGMEA University of Fashion and Technology, Bangladesh
2Department of EEE, University of Dhaka, Bangladesh
*Corresponding Author: Md. Selim Reza, Department of Natural Sciences, BGMEA University of Fashion and Technology, Bangladesh, Tel: +8801724479348 Email: ,

Abstract

Fire accidents are causing a huge human death as well as economic losses throughout the world every year. But novel fire detection and extinguishing system could reduce these losses to a great extent. We are proposing a cost effective and yet very efficient system which has been developed in our laboratory and evaluated while in operation. Our system consists of two units: detection unit and extinguishing unit. For detection purposes we used smoke, IR and temperature sensors. While for extinguishing purposes we used both foam and water. We used a PC to process and control our system through LabVIEW software of National Instrument, USA. The detection unit will send signal through a wireless module to PC if fire is detected. Then PC (LabVIEW) will process the signal and using relay module first of all the electric power and gas lines will be turned off. The extinguishing unit will then release foam or water to extinguish the fire. The system will send SMS to the predefined numbers using GSM module. Our system is location independent as it uses GSM and can be operated from remote location using wireless module. After performance evaluation, it was found to be fast and reliable.

 

Keywords: Detection unit; Extinguishing unit; IR; SMS; GSM module; Wireless module; LabVIEW; Foam

Introduction

We are in an advanced world of technology. But it has been noticed with great concern that the fire accidents and casualties are also increasing proportionally every year. According to the yearly report, 2018 of International Association of Fire and Rescue Services average number of fires (2012 to 2016) only in USA is 1320100 per year [1]. According to Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense, fire incidents kill 233 people and injure 5000 every year in Bangladesh. In 2016 alone there has been 16858 fire incidents in Bangladesh causing 240 crore and 43 lakh financial loss, killed 152 and 247 were injured [2]. According to the National Fire Protection Association, USA some main reasons behind fire accidents are i) flammable liquids and gases, ii) faulty equipment and machinery and iii) electrical hazards [3]. So to cope up these disasters we need to design a smart detection and extinguishing system on the basis of above mentioned reasons. There has been a huge effort over the years to design and develop such systems. Feiniu Yuan [4] designed a fire detection and suppression system based on widely available video surveillance. He used traditional CCD cameras for fire recognition and water gun for suppression [4]. Antidio Viguria et al. [5] proposed a system that utilizes heterogeneous robots (aerial and ground) for fire detection and extinguishing purposes. They developed a distributed market-based algorithm called S+T to solve the multirobot task allocation problem. Lee et al. [6] developed a fire detection system based on controller area network (CAN). We are proposing a LabVIEW based fire detection and extinguishing system which is cost effective and reliable (Tables 1 and 2).

Number Country Population, thousand inh. Number of fires Average
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Per year Per thousand inh. a year
1 USA 323128 1375000 1240000 1298000 1345500 12342000 1320100 4.09
2 Russia 146270 162900 152959 150437 145900 139500 150339 1.03
3 France 66628 306871 281908 270900 300667 285700 289209 4.34
4 Great Britain 63786 272800 192700 212500 191647 201009 214131 3.36
5 Spain 47079 142500 135000 128000 137000 122828 133066 2.83

Table 1: Trends in fires in some of the countries of the world in 2012-2016.

Number Country Population, thousand inh. Number of fires Average number per
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Year 100000 inh. 100 fires
1 USA 323,128 2855 3420 3275 3280 3390 3244 1 0.2
2 Russia 146270 11652 10601 10138 9405 8749 10109 6.9 6.7
3 France 66628 362 321 280 335 289 317 0.5 0.1
4 Great Britain 63786 380 350 322 325 344 0.5 0.2
5 Spain 47079 170 132 162 143 175 156 0.3 0.1

Table 2: Trends in fire deaths in some of the countries of the world in 2012-2016.

Methodology

Our system consists of three units i) detection unit, ii) receiving and processing unit and iii) warning and extinguishing unit. The detection unit is responsible for the detection of fire. It consists of three sensors and a transmitter. We used MQ-5 gas sensor, IR sensor and LM35 temperature sensor for detection purpose. For transmission purposes we used JMR-TX1 Transmission module. The receiving part will receive the transmitted signal from the detection unit. The processing part will confirm the detection of fire following some specific criteria. The warning unit is for raising awareness among the inhabitants with the help of Siren and SMS. The responsibility of the extinguishing unit is to suppress fire after detection. We used both foam and water for extinguishing purpose. Figure below shows the block diagram of our system (Figure 1).

advancements-technology-block-diagram

Figure 1: Block diagram of the system.

Detection Unit

Detection is one of the main parts of an extinguishing system and is based on various properties of fire such as smoke emission, rise in temperature and optical radiation emission [7,8]. We used MQ-5 sensor for detection of gas and smoke, LM35 temperature sensor for detection of rise in temperature and SKU152020 IR flame sensor for detection of optical flames. The MQ-5 is chosen because it has high sensitivity, faster response, long life and it needs simple circuitry to drive. It can detect propane and butane as well as other natural gases, cigarette smoke and alcohol. The LM35 is selected as it doesn’t need any external calibration or trimming for precision measurement in Centigrade scale. By analyzing optical properties of fire we can find that it will emit some ultra violet and even some x-rays but that amount is negligible. Most of the radiation emitted is in the infrared spectrum as shown in Figure 2 [8]. So we selected the SKU152020 IR flame sensor module for the detection of optical flame. A separate PCB has been made combining these sensors along with a transmitter for accurate detection and transmission of the signal to the receiving unit. We used ATmega8 microcontroller for proper operation of the unit and compiled it with BASCOM AVR. The flow chart of Figure 3 explains the operation of the detection unit.

advancements-technology-typical-emission

Figure 2: Typical emission spectrum of hydrocarbon fire.

advancements-technology-detection-unit

Figure 3: Flow chart explaining the operation of the detection unit.

Receiving and Processing Unit

The detection unit will send voltage output signal in the form of string to the receiver via RF transmitter. A separate PCB has been developed containing a RF receiver and PIC16 microprocessor and is connected to PC through USB port. The received signal will be processed by LabVIEW program which is a popular measuring and controlling software from the National Instrument, USA. A virtual instrument has been made in this purpose. The MQ-5 will always send GAS if gas/smoke is detected to the receiver. The program will then compare whether the string (GAS) is matched or not. In the same way the flame sensor module will send FLAME if detected to the receiver. The program will then compare weather the string (FLAME) is matched or not. The LM35 will send the temperature reading in centigrade to the receiver. The program will check whether the reading is equal or greater than 100ºC. Following table shows the general temperatures of sources of ignition and from it we decided to confirm fire temperature to be 100ºC and more [9]. If these criteria are met the program will confirm the detection of fire and will move to the next step. The whole process of the receiving and processing unit is shown in the flow chart of Figure 4 (Table 3).

advancements-technology-processing-unit

Figure 4: Mechanism of receiving and processing unit.

Source Temperature (Celsius)
Cigarettes - ventilated 400°- 780º
Cigarettes - unventilated conditions 288°
Cigarettes - insulated and smoldering 510°-621°
Match 600°- 800°
Candle flame 600°- 1400°
Stove element >550°
Fluorescent light 60°- 80°
Incandescent light 100°- 300°
Tungsten halogen light 600°- 900°
Electrical arcing 3750°
Electrical spark 1316°
Lightning 30000°
Oxyacetylene 3300°
Industrial furnaces 1700°
Bunsen burner 1570°

Table 3: Sources of ignition-general temperatures.

Warning and Extinguishing Unit

The warning part consists of a relay based siren and GSM based Short Message Service (SMS). When fire is detected the LabVIEW will send voltage signal to the Data Acquisition (DAQ) card and will activate the solid state relay. The mini siren will be activated immediately which is connected to the relay. In addition, the system will send SMS to the related person using GSM modem. The extinguishing part consists of a solenoid valve, fire extinguisher and related pipe, nozzle, etc. When fire is detected the voltage signal will be send to the relay through DAQ card. Then the solenoid valve which is connected to the relay will be activated which will unleash the fire extinguisher (foam or water). The fire extinguishing agent will extinguish the flame or gas with pipes and nozzles. The flow chart in Figure 5 describes the mechanism of the warning and extinguishing unit.

advancements-technology-extinguishing-unit

Figure 5: Mechanism of the warning and extinguishing unit of our system.

Performance Evaluation

Our developed system has been tested under certain circumstances. The detection speed of Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG), Natural Gas and Town Gas is very fast. Within seconds of their occurrence our system can detect them. However for cigarette smoke and cooking fumes the system response is a bit slow. The lighter and denser flame can also be detected with very high accuracy and fast response. The following table summarizes the test result of the detection unit (Table 4). The system response of warning and extinguishing unit under certain circumstances are summarized in the following table. For 50 cm and lower distances between the detection and receiving unit we found that the system sometimes gets jammed. It would be due to fact of interference between siren and DAQ card. However the response of the system is generally satisfactory. However with the increase in distance between the detection and receiving unit the system responses slowly. It is due to the fact that we used low cost sensors and RF module with small detection ranges (Table 5).

Number Materials Response Range
1 LPG very fast N/A
2 Natural Gas fast N/A
3 Town Gas fast N/A
4 Cigarette smoke very slow N/A
5 Cooking fumes very slow N/A
6 Lighter Flame (Any type) very fast 75 cm
7 Denser Flame (Any type) very fast 100 cm

Table 4: Response of the detection unit for various gases.

Number Distance between transmitter and receiver Response Alarm SMS Extinguisher
1 50 cm Very fast Jammed Immediately Rapid
2 100 cm Very fast Immediately Immediately Rapid
3 200 cm Very fast Immediately Immediately Rapid
4 10 m Fast Average Immediately Average
5 50m Average Average Immediately Average
6 100m No response No response No response No response

Table 5: Response of different units in terms of distance between transmitter and receiver.

Conclusion

A novel automatic PC based fire detection and extinguishing system has been designed and tested. LabVIEW software has been used to develop the virtual instrument as the main control panel and found perfectly working after several tests. The system integrates gas, flame and temperature sensors, interfacing board, relay module, RF module, solenoid valve, fire extinguisher (foam and water), alarm and GSM modem to function with the command from PC through USB port. The prototype system is enabling to detect fire within few seconds of their occurrence and take necessary measure. With the achievement of all the objectives of this research, we can conclude that the designed system is reliable and cost effective which could be employed as an automatic firefighter in industries to reduce the number of casualties and loss of assets.

Future Work

The system consists of only three sensors. So it is therefore recommended that a system which accepts as many inputs from sensors as may be required by the user be designed. This may be possible by use of multiplexers. Multi-time usable fire extinguishers are necessary for future upgrades. When these are achieved, detection as well as control of fire will be achieved for a large area. Due to various environmental factors i.e. change in pressure, air flow, etc. normal flow of smoke may be diverted to undesired detection unit. It may trigger undesirable fire extinguisher and would lead to inefficiency. Sensor that uses the coordinate system to check the direction of the flow before triggering the sprinklers is thus required. In addition, sensors that are immune to strong heat, high humidity and dust repellant are also required to enhance the degree of accuracy.

References

  1. Brushlinsky NN, Ahrens M, Sokolov SV, Wanger P (2018) World Fire Statistics.
  2. https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/nation/2017/03/17/many-recent-fires
  3. Yuan F (2010) An integrated fire detection and suppression system based on widely available video surveillance. Mach Vision Appl 21: 941-948.
  4. Antidio Viguria, Ivan Maza, Anibal Ollero (2010) distributed service-based cooperation in aerial/ground robot teams applied to fire detection and extinguishing missions. Adv Robotics 24: 1-23
  5. Lee KC, Hong HL (2004) Network-based fire-detection system via controller area network for smart home automation. IEEE Trans Consumer Electron 50: 1093-1100.
  6. Turns SR (2018) An introduction to combustion: Concepts and applications.
  7. Cardoulis JN (1990) The Art and Science of Fire Investigation Hardcover.
Citation: Reza MS, Mamun SM (2018) Development and Performance Evaluation of a Novel Fire Detection and Extinguishing System: Towards Industrial Automation. Int J Adv Technol 9: 218.

Copyright: © 2018 Reza MS, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Top