ISSN: 2155-9899
Review Article - (2014) Volume 5, Issue 5
Lymphatic vessels have been traditionally considered as passive transporters of lipids particularly from the intestine. However, it became apparent from emerging research that lymphatic vessel can play a more extensive role in lipid metabolism than previously realized. Moreover, recent evidence reveals that lipid deposition in the form of white adipose tissue or cholesterol as observed in obesity or hypercholesterolemia, respectively, may perturb lymphatic function. This Review summarizes the evidence supporting a bidirectional relationship between lymphatic function and the deposition of white adipose or cholesterol in peripheral tissue in the context of obesity and hypercholesterolemia. We also discuss potential mechanisms whereby excessive fat or cholesterol accumulation in tissue may account for lymphatic dysfunction. We particularly consider how phenotypic and functional changes in adipose tissue as well as in macrophages accompanying obesity and hypercholesterolemia may affect the lymphatic vasculature. In addition to their transport function, lymphatic vessels play essential roles in regulating inflammatory and adaptive immune responses. Therefore, we highlight how lymphatic dysfunction associated with hypercholesterolemia may influence immunity, inflammation and the significance to atherosclerosis. The emerging importance of the lymphatic system in lipid metabolism and immunity underscores the urgent need to find pharmacological or surgical interventions that can improve lymphatic function which are currently not available.
Keywords: Lymphatic vessel; Adipose tissue; Hypercholesterolemia; Macrophage; Adipocyte; Atherosclerosis; Immunity
The lymphatic circulation that runs in conjunction with the blood circulation plays an essential role in maintaining body-fluid homeostasis, immunity, and lipid transport from the intestine [1]. The lymphatic system is composed of an extensive network of lymphatic vessels and interconnected lymph nodes. To accomplish its functions, it must transport lymph from the interstitial spaces into and through the lymphatic vessels, the thoracic duct and back to the blood circulation [1]. This movement of lymph containing lipids, cells, macromolecules and fluid is first collected by initial or capillary lymphatic vessels which are identified by the expression of podoplanin, lymphatic vessel hyaluronan receptor 1 (LYVE-1) and the absence of smooth muscle cells. Lymph is then transported to larger lymphatic vessels, the collecting vessels, in which initial lymphatic vessels converge. Collecting vessels also express podoplanin but down-regulate LYVE-1 expression and exhibit circumferential smooth muscle cell coverage and luminal valves that propel and maintain unidirectional flow. Recent advances in lymphatic biology and functions have demonstrated that lymphatic vessels are not “inert conduits” but rather plastic structures that actively sense and respond to the tissue environment. They also participate in many pathological conditions such as cancer, infectious and chronic inflammatory diseases. For example, inflammation can affect the structure and function of lymphatic vessels and lymph nodes, and such lymphatic remodelling can have important biological consequences including modulation of inflammation and adaptive immune responses [2-4]. Moreover, the relationship between lipids and lymphatic function and its significance in lipid-related pathologies have just recently begun to receive attention [5] although the absorption and transport of fat by intestinal lymphatic vessels have been known for centuries.
Hypercholesterolemia is a condition characterized by high levels of cholesterol in the blood. It is the major risk factor for atherosclerotic disease and is also a common clinical feature in diabetes, obesity, systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and psoriasis. Obesity relates to the accumulation of excess body fat determined by the measurement of the body mass index, and is also a major risk factor for cardiovascular diseases. Even though both medical conditions often overlap, it is important to understand their pathologies as separate entities to elucidate their relative implications. Although obesity is frequently associated with hypercholesterolemia and the combination of both conditions worsened cardiovascular risk status, many obese patients exhibit normal blood lipid profile [6]. Similarly, many hypercholesterolemic patients are not obese [7]. However, the obvious similarity between obesity and hypercholesterolemia is the accumulation of lipids in extravascular tissues. Lipid deposition appears in the form of white adipose expansion or foam cells also known as xanthomas in obesity and hypercholesterolemia, respectively. It is worthy of note that foam cell accumulation has been reported in obesity [8,9] but, it is not known whether adipocyte hypertrophy associated with obesity may also manifest in hypercholesterolemia. This Review summarizes the evidence revealing and supporting a bidirectional relationship between the lymphatic system and lipid accumulation in tissues occurring in the context of obesity and hypercholesterolemia. In addition, the potential mechanisms by which excess white adipose or cholesterol in tissues may alter the function of lymphatic vessels are discussed. Finally, the possible immunological consequences of lymphatic dysfunction associated with hypercholesterolemia are also considered.
Evidence connecting lymphatic function with adipose tissue accumulation
Over the past decade, a growing body of evidence from studies in small animal models and human diseases has supported that lymphatic dysfunction often leads to adipose tissue accumulation. Such effect is well illustrated in patients suffering from lymphedema [10]. Lymphedema arises as a consequence of impaired lymph transport which results either from abnormal lymphatic vessel development (primary or hereditary lymphedema) or from lymphatic vascular damage or infection (secondary or acquired lymphedema). If lymphedema is not resolved, patients with primary or secondary lymphedema typically exhibit local edema which follows the retention of interstitial fluid and proteins in the affected tissues. As disease progresses, immune cell infiltration, tissue fibrosis and most relevant to this review, excessive fat accumulation occur [10-12]. In fact, liposuction of lymphedema revealed that fat rather than fluid deposition mainly accounts for tissue swelling [12]. Adipose tissue accumulation has also been described in surgically-induced [13,14] or naturally occurring mouse models of secondary lymphedema. The Chy mice which lacked dermal lymphatic vessels as a result of an inactivating mutation in Vegfr3 gene exhibited thickening of the subcutaneous fat [13]. Inactivation of Prox1, a gene encoding for a transcription factor critical for lymphatic vasculature development [15-17], in mouse leads to lymphatic vasculature leakage and the development of adult-onset obesity [16]. Interestingly, the authors of this latter study demonstrated that the degree of lymphatic defect correlates with the magnitude of adipose tissue deposition in mice haploinsufficient for Prox1 and that the lymph leaking from this defective lymphatic vasculature promotes the differentiation of adipocytes. This adipogenic property of lymph was in fact reported in earlier work [18] and has been associated with changes in temporal and spatial expression of CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein-α and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-γ which control adipocyte differentiation [19]. Further investigations are warranted to determine whether these mechanisms described in mouse models of lymphedema also account for the fat deposition observed in patients with lymphedema.
Whereas there are strong clinical and experimental data supporting that defects in lymphatic function often lead to fat deposition in peripheral tissues, the impact of adipose tissue accumulation on lymphatic function has only recently begun to be appreciated (Figure 1). In humans, there are some reports showing that obesity is associated with lymphatic impairment [20,21] but not all [22], therefore further confirmation awaits. Two recent studies reported that diet-induced obesity (DIO) in rodents was accompanied by impaired lymphatic flow [23,24] and this impairment was, in part, due to vessel wall dilation and reduced contractile activity of collecting lymphatic vessels [23]. As a result of compromised lymphatic flow, DIO mice developed a more severe phenotype in surgical-induced lymphedema as compared to lean control animals [25]. These findings may provide an explanation as to why obesity or weight gain following sentinel lymph node biopsy or axillary lymph node dissection are predisposing factors for lymphedema although the mechanisms involved are likely more complex [26,27].
Evidence connecting lymphatic function with tissue cholesterol accumulation
The impact of lymphatic dysfunction is not limited to adipose tissue expansion and has recently been extended to cholesterol accumulation in tissues (Figure 1). Cells have developed complex mechanisms to regulate the abundance of intracellular cholesterol since an excess can be detrimental. Among these mechanisms, the process referred to reverse cholesterol transport (RCT) has been shown to be critical for the removal of excess cholesterol from peripheral tissues and its transport to the liver via plasma for excretion [28]. RCT is initiated when cells including macrophages efflux the excess of cholesterol to prevent intracellular over-accumulation. This step is tightly regulated through the action of ATP-binding cassette transporters ABCA1, ABCG1 and scavenger receptor class BI (SR-BI) and high density lipoprotein (HDL) which serves as the major acceptor for cellular cholesterol released in the extrahepatic tissues [29]. Following cholesterol efflux, HDL-cholesterol is transported from the tissue back into the blood circulation. In the final step of RCT, the majority of HDL-derived cholesterol is removed from the liver by secretion into the bile [28,29]. In contrast to the knowledge on the mechanisms by which cholesterol is effluxed from the cells and its fate after reaching the liver, little information is available on how HDL-cholesterol travels from the peripheral tissues back to the blood circulation. Since one of the major roles of lymphatic vessels is to drain macromolecules from the interstitial space back to the circulation and lymph is rich in cholesterol and HDL [30-32], the implication of lymphatic vessel in the transport of lipoproteins from interstitium to blood was proposed [33] and re-established recently by two separate groups. The study of Martel et al., [34] in Chy mice and our study [35] in wild-type mice in which lymphatic vessels were surgically excised clearly provide the first direct evidence that poor lymphatic drainage significantly decreased the efficiency of RCT. We also further proposed that the transport of effluxed cholesterol from peripheral tissue to the circulation via lymphatics is not only passive as anticipated but can be an active process dependent on HDL and SR-BI [35]. These new findings support the concept that lymphatic vessels tightly regulate the clearance of cholesterol from the peripheral tissues through the transport of HDL-cholesterol [31] (Figure 1). There are some indications that such concept may also hold in humans. Indeed, isolated case reports of xanthomas in primary lymphedema patients have been described in the dermatologic literature since the 60’s [36-40]. Cholesterol accumulation in tissues as a result of poor lymphatic function may also increase the adipocyte burden to store more lipids thereby increasing deposition of fat [41,42].
Figure 1: Interplay between obesity and/or hypercholesterolemia and lymphatic function. Accumulation of white adipose or cholesterol in tissues in response to obesity or hypercholesterolemia, respectively, has been shown to potentially affect the structure and/or function of initial and collecting lymphatic vessels. Conversely, poor lymphatic drainage has been proposed to contribute to the accumulation of adipose tissue and cholesterol in tissues. As a consequence, this interplay is expected to impact inflammation, diabetes and cardiovascular diseases.
Xanthomas including tendon xanthomas are a clinical feature that often manifest in human familial hypercholesterolemia [43,44]. Notably, hypercholesterolemic mice including mice lacking apolipoprotein E (apoE-/-) or low density lipoprotein receptor (Ldlr-/-) have been shown to develop peripheral skin edema. The edematous tissues in these mice were found to consist predominantly of cholesterol deposits and formation of foam cells [35,45,46]. Our group has reported that hypercholesterolemia in apoE-/- and Ldlr-/- mice leads to severe skin lymphatic dysfunction as reducing hypercholesterolemia with ezetimibe treatment improves lymphatic function and cholesterol clearance from skin [35,47]. Impairment of lymphatic function in these mice was associated with initial lymphatic vessel hyperplasia, loss of collecting vessel identity as shown by poor smooth muscle cell coverage [47]. These structural changes that likely account for lymphatic dysfunction observed in hypercholesterolemic mice (Figure 1) may result from a decreased in vascular endothelial growth factor-C (VEGF-C), FOXC2 and angiopoietin-2 expression [35], which are important factors to maintain lymphatic vasculature [35,47]. It remains unclear whether lymphatic dysfunction occurs in humans with hypercholesterolemia. A study in patients with familial combined hyperlipidemia reporting lower gene expression of FOXC-2 and Prox-1 in their adipose tissues is consistent with this idea [48].
Collectively, these studies support the link between accumulation of white adipose or cholesterol in tissue and lymphatic function. Moreover, they raise the possibility of a two-way relationship between lipid homeostasis and lymphatic function with the potential to set up a positive feedback: changes in adipose tissue or cholesterol content may impair lymphatic drainage in peripheral tissues, and this loss of lymphatic function may render the tissue susceptible to further and more profound alterations in adipose tissue or cholesterol accumulation (Figure 1). In the following section, we discuss potential mechanisms whereby excessive fat or cholesterol accumulation in tissue may account for lymphatic dysfunction. Although we focus specifically on how alterations in adipose tissue and macrophages accompanying obesity and hypercholesterolemia may impact lymphatic function, we acknowledge that additional pathways may be involved or be uncovered in the near future.
Changes in adipose tissue
The adipose tissue consists of adipocytes, precursor cells, fibroblasts, collagen-rich connective tissues, blood capillaries, nerve fibres, fibroblasts and macrophages. It is no longer perceived as just a reservoir for energy stores but rather as an endocrine organ which releases many bioactive substances termed adipokines. Among them, adiponectin, leptin, interleukin-6 (IL-6) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) are critical determinants of various metabolic and physiological function [49]. Therefore, the absence of adipose tissue results in detrimental metabolic changes. Similar to humans suffering from lipoatrophy [50], mice lacking white adipose tissue develop insulin resistance, hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia and fatty liver [51]. Transplantation of wild-type adipose tissue into these lipoatrophic mice completely reversed the phenotype [51]. During obesity, although adipogenesis occurs, the white adipose tissue also undergoes negative remodelling characterized by adipocyte hypertrophy and followed by death [52]. These structural changes in adipose tissue during obesity lead to an alteration in adipokine production which in turn results in insulin resistance, hyperglycemia, endothelium dysfunction and fatty liver [53]. In sum, the adipose tissue is clearly essential for health, and therefore, when it is imbalanced major deleterious effects on the body system arise. The fact that adipose tissue always surrounds the lymphatic vessels and lymph nodes [54] raises the possibility that changes in adipose tissue may account for the lymphatic dysfunction observed in obesity and hypercholesterolemia. Indeed, we detected morphological changes in the subcutaneous adipose tissue of hypercholesterolemic apoE-/- mice similar to those described in obese mice (unpublished data). Pond and colleagues have shown that during chronic inflammation, the adipose tissue surrounding the lymph nodes expands and increases its rate of lipolysis to fuel the inflammation [55,56]. Therefore, the adipose tissue surrounding the lymphatic vessels may also provide energy or adipokines to maintain the lymphatic vasculature (Figure 2). Adiponectin is exclusively expressed by adipocytes, and serum adiponectin concentration inversely correlates with increasing obesity [57,58]. Recently, Shumizu and colleagues [59] demonstrated the importance of adiponectin in resolving lymphedema as adiponectin deficient mice develop a more severe phenotype in surgical-induced lymphedema and the administration of adiponectin in obese mice ameliorates lymphedema [59]. In vitro, treatment of adiponectin has been shown to stimulate lymphatic vessel formation and maintain vessel viability via AMPK/Akt/endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) signalling pathways [59]. Nitric oxide is known to regulate lymphatic pumping through its action on lymphatic smooth muscle cells [60,61]. Therefore, given the effect of adiponectin in the regulation of arterial tone via nitric oxide [62,63], it is also possible that administration of adiponectin could improve collecting vessel structure and function in obese mice (Figure 2).
Figure 2: Possible mechanisms contributing to impaired lymphatic function during obesity and/or hypercholesterolemia. In skin, dermal blind-ended initial lymphatic vessels converge into collecting vessels, which are covered with smooth muscles and feed into the draining lymph node (not represented here). Under healthy condition, macrophages present in both the dermis and subcutaneous fat and adipocytes may maintain the morphology and the function of lymphatic vessels by secreting vascular endothelial growth factor-C (VEGF-C) and adiponectin as well as controlling the expression of eNOS. In contrast, obesity and hypercholesterolemia have been shown to induce infiltration of macrophages which transform into foam cells upon cholesterol uptake and adipocyte hypertrophy and death. Under these conditions, adipocytes produce reduced amount of adiponectin but increased reactive oxygen species (ROS) which have been shown to reduce lymphatic pumping activity. Lipid-laden macrophages may show reduced capacity to produce VEGF-C. Furthermore, obesity is associated with increased deposition of extracellular matrix (ECM), particularly collagen which may in turn affect lymphatic vasculature. Altogether, these alterations in macrophage and adipocyte along with fibrosis may lead to lymphatic vessel dilation and impaired lymphatic transport.
Obesity in mice and humans has also been reported to be associated with increased oxidative stress in circulation and adipose tissue [64]. Furthermore, lipid-laden cultured adipocytes exhibit an increased content in reactive oxygen species metabolites [65]. Because such metabolites have been shown to inhibit mesentery collecting lymphatic contractility [66], it is likely that the increased oxidative environment in adipose tissue during obesity may also impair lymphatic function (Figure 2). Another possible change in adipose tissue accompanying obesity that may potentially affect lymphatic function is fibrosis (Figure 2). In obesity, the adipose tissue is a major site of fibrosis [67]. Interestingly, fibrosis has been reported to inhibit lymphatic regeneration and function in mouse model of lymphedema [68,69]. During lymphedema, fibrosis in the subcutaneous adipose tissue and collecting lymphatic vessels occurs [14,19,70]. As a consequence of the increase in collagen fibres, collecting lymphatic vessels lose their elastic properties. These pathological changes resemble a condition known as aortic stiffening. In this condition, fractured elastin and increased collagen in the aorta affect the mechanical properties of the aortic wall ultimately, resulting in vasodilation and vasoconstriction dysfunction [71]. Similarly, fibrosis on the collecting lymphatic vessels may impede their contractility and impair lymph transport. Consistent with this hypothesis, obesity-associated fibrosis has been recently proposed to contribute to the exacerbation of lymphatic dysfunction in a mouse model of lymphedema [25].
Alterations in macrophage
Obesity is associated with increased macrophage infiltration in adipose tissue [9,72,73]. These macrophages elicit a chronic low-grade inflammation by producing proinflammatory mediators such as TNFα, inducible nitric oxide, IL-6, and IL-1β which, potently impair adipocyte lipid metabolism, augment insulin resistance and promote tissue fibrosis [73,74]. The ablation of macrophages in obese mice reduced inflammation and improved insulin sensitivity [75]. Similarly, in humans, weight loss induced by gastric bypass or low energy diet was accompanied in the adipose tissue by a reduction in macrophage content and a concomitant decrease in inflammatory markers [72,76]. Whereas all these studies highlight the contribution of infiltrating macrophages in obesity-related complications, the phenotype of these macrophages remain uncertain. Macrophages have been traditionally classified into M1 and M2 macrophages. In this classification, M1 and M2 designation refer to classically activated macrophage and alternatively activated macrophage, respectively [77]. In obese mice, the inflammatory M1 macrophages predominate in the adipose tissues as opposed to the resident non-inflammatory M2 macrophages which are present in lean mice [78,79]. However, one study reported the presence of macrophages with a mixed M1/M2 profile in obese mice [80]. Similarly, in humans, one study described the predominance of M1 macrophage in adipose tissue during obesity [81] whereas another study reported the presence of macrophages expressing M1-M2 surface markers [74]. Furthermore, some studies have shown that despite the expression of M2 surface markers, the majority of these macrophages exhibit both anti-inflammatory and inflammatory features [82,83]. Notably, similar picture has been drawn regarding the phenotype of macrophages that accumulate during hypercholesterolemia associated with atherosclerotic disease [84]. It is possible that the phenotype of macrophages may vary during the course of obesity and hypercholesterolemia as changes in their surrounding tissue are expected over time. This may explain these conflicting results about macrophage phenotype in obesity and hypercholesterolemia. These studies may also highlight the limitations of characterizing macrophage populations during these medical conditions on the basis of M1/M2 classification. A new grouping of macrophage populations based on their functions as proposed [85] should be considered.
So far, research on the involvement of macrophages in regulating lymphatic vessels has mainly focused on their effect on the growth of lymphatic vessels, a process also called lymphangiogenesis, in the context of inflammation and development. Therefore, it is unknown whether they may also maintain lymphatic function and structure under homeostatic conditions. Macrophages have been reported to either act as lymphatic progenitor cells [86-88] or to produce lymphangiogenic factors including VEGF-C and VEGF-D [88-91]. In addition to its lymphangiogenic property, VEGF-C can also control the pumping activity of collecting vessels [92] and dilation of initial lymphatic vessels [93] (Figure 2). Ablation of macrophages inhibit lymphangiogenesis which delays resolution of inflammation [90] and macrophage-deficient mice develop severe lymphatic hyperplasia during development [94]. It is unclear whether these “prolymphangiogenic” macrophages are of M1 or M2 phenotype. Some studies have identified them based on the surface expression of lymphatic vessel endothelial hyaluronic acid receptor-1 (LYVE-1) [94-96]. Notably, LYVE-1+ positive macrophages have been reported in the adipose tissue of rodents [97] and humans [83]. Interestingly, down-regulation of VEGF-C expression was reported in adipose tissue from obese individuals compared to lean controls [98]. Similarly, we demonstrated recently that the lymphatic dysfunction observed in skin of hypercholesterolemic mice is associated with decreased VEGF-C expression. Administration of VEGF-C restores lymphatic function in these mice which in turn promotes cholesterol clearance [35]. Furthermore, analysis of macrophages in apoE-/- mice revealed that they massively accumulate in skin and the majority uptake lipids and become foam cells [35]. Interestingly, these lipid-laden macrophages express negligible amount of VEGF-C compared to resident macrophage in normocholesterolemic skin (unpublished data, Figure 2). Few scenarios may explain the decreased expression of VEGF-C by these macrophages, namely: macrophages may lose their capacity to produce VEGF-C once they become foam cells or the hypercholesterolemic environment may promote the recruitment and/or differentiation of a population of macrophage which does not express VEGF-C. The latter idea may also apply to obesity because adipokines whose production by adipocytes is affected during obesity can modulate macrophage function. Adiponectin seems to be a good candidate since it has been recently reported in vitro to induce VEGF-C production by macrophages [99]. Moreover, adiponectin levels are decreased during obese states in which lymphatic function is impaired [57,58]. Taken together, these findings support macrophage dysfunction as a possible contributor to lymphatic impairment during lipid-related disorders which needs further considerations (Figure 2).
Given the emerging contribution of the lymphatic system in regulating inflammatory [3] and adaptive immune responses [2], we discuss here how lymphatic dysfunction in hypercholesterolemia may alter immunological processes (Table 1). Lymphatic vessels are now recognized by immunologists as important routes for the migration of dendritic cells and lymphocytes from peripheral tissue into the draining lymph nodes and for the egress of lymphocytes from the lymph nodes [4,100-102]. Moreover, lymph fluid drains soluble antigens to the draining lymph nodes [103]. Therefore, lymphatic vessels can regulate immune responses by supporting the interactions between antigen-presenting cells and rare-antigen specific T cells in lymph nodes as well as the recirculation of lymphocytes. In apoE-/- mice, lymphatic dysfunction severely compromises the migration of skin dendritic cells to the draining lymph nodes, and conversely, improving lymphatic drainage restores dendritic cell migration [35,47,104]. It is possible that the trafficking of lymphocytes out of the lymph nodes may also be affected in apoE-/- mice since these mice exhibit hypertrophic lymph node as shown by a significant increase in cellularity [47,104]. Such alterations in immune cell trafficking are expected to impact immune priming and memory responses [2]. This may explain the increased susceptibility of hypercholesterolemic mice to infections [105-107]. Lymphatic endothelial cells have been shown to modulate the activation of T cell through the presentation of antigens via MHC class I [108-110] and class II [111,112] as well as T cell homeostasis through the production of immunoregulatory cytokines [113-115]. Therefore, it would be interesting to evaluate whether these functions of the lymphatic endothelium are affected in hypercholesterolemic mice.
1 | Transport of soluble antigens |
2 | Immune cell (dendritic cell, lymphocyte) emigration from peripheral tissues |
3 | Lymphocyte egress from draining lymph node |
4 | Resolution of inflammation |
5 | Development of tertiary lymphoid organs |
6 | Presentation of antigen by lymphatic endothelium |
7 | T lymphocyte activation |
8 | T lymphocyte homeostasis |
Table 1: Immunologic processes potentially altered as a result of lymphatic dysfunction.
Hypercholesterolemia is a major risk factor of atherosclerosis which is a chronic inflammatory disease of medium and large arteries. Arteries are composed of three layers, namely: the intima or inner layer, followed by the media and the most outer layer, the adventitia. Atherosclerosis affecting predominantly the coronary arteries in humans and the aorta in mouse results from the progressive build-up of plaques within the intimal tissue. Accumulation of cholesterol, immune cells and fibrous elements along with inflammation are the hallmark of this chronic inflammatory disease. The intima has been a major focus of research on atherosclerosis and the processes within the vessel wall have been well-characterized. In contrast, changes in the adventitia during atherosclerosis and the physiological and/or pathological role of this layer have been largely neglected. In addition to macrophages, fibroblast, T cells and mast cells, the adventitia contains blood and lymphatic vessels. As other chronic inflammatory diseases affecting the skin, kidney, eye, airways and the gut [3,4], atherosclerosis has also been recently associated with lymphangiogenesis in the adventitia [116-118]. However, further investigations will be necessary to establish whether lymphangiogenesis is an element of the pathology or a productive attempt to resolve atherosclerosis. Since we showed that hypercholesterolemic apoE-/- mice, which also develop atherosclerosis exhibit compromised lymphatic transport in skin, the function of these newly formed or existing adventitial lymphatic vessels may also be altered during atherogenesis. Interestingly, a link between disrupted flow and atherogenesis was postulated as far back as five decades ago [119-123]. It was reported that lymphatic ligation at the level of renal arteries in mongrel dogs increases connective tissue surrounding the obstructed lymphatic vessels and promotes intimal thickening [120]. Similar observations were made after ligating cardiac lymph nodes [119]. Finally, examination of resected colon carcinoma specimens revealed atherosclerotic changes only in those sections of arteries in which tumor infiltrates obstructed lymphatic drainage [123]. Consistent with these early observations, a recent study by Vuorio et al., [124] demonstrated that crossing mice exhibiting lymphatic insufficiency, chy mice and soluble vascular endothelial receptor-3, with atherosclerotic mice enhances cholesterol and triglyceride levels and atherogenesis. Using a surgical model in which the donor aortic arch was transplanted into the abdominal cavity of a recipient mouse, Martel et al., [34] reported that blocking the regeneration of lymphatic vessels after surgery significantly inhibit the clearance of cholesterol by RCT.
Altogether, these studies support the concept that poor lymph flow may contribute to the atherosclerotic process by disturbing the balance of lipoproteins in the arterial wall. HDL, which selectively passes through arterial endothelium and binds cholesterol, may be unable to drain through lymphatic vessels and carry cholesterol to the liver for metabolism as bile acids. As a consequence, cholesterol will accumulate in the arterial wall. LDL which transports lipids into the arterial wall will continue to deposit cholesterol and triglycerides, even in the presence of defective lymph flow. By inducing protein stasis in the arterial wall, impaired lymphatic drainage may also promote local inflammatory reactions as observed during lymphedema [10] which will likely influence plaque progression and stability. As we observed in skin of atherosclerotic mice [104], impaired lymphatic drainage may also alter the emigration of immune cells from the arteries including dendritic cells [125] and lymphocytes [126,127], which actively participate in atherosclerosis. As discussed above, such alterations in immune cell trafficking will likely affect adaptive immune responses. Finally, defective lymphatic drainage may support the development of tertiary lymphoid organs (TLOs) as suggested in chronic graft rejection [128]. TLOs also named ectopic lymphoid tissues are accumulations of cells emerging in response to chronic inflammation [129,130]. They share similar organization and structure with lymph nodes except the absence of capsule. Interestingly, TLOs have been identified in the aortic adventitia of aged apoE-/- mice during atherosclerosis and shown to exhibit aberrant lymphangiogenesis [131,132]. Similarly, infiltrates of leukocytes in adventitia of coronary arteries of patients with atherosclerosis as well as B cell follicle-like aggregates in human aorta have been described [133,134]. Given the proposed contribution of TLOs in primary immune response and in autoimmune responses in advanced atherosclerosis [132], the functions of these TLOs lymphatic vessels deserve to be investigated.
There is no doubt that tremendous progress has been made on the role of lymphatic vessels in lipid transport since the first description of milky white vessels in the mesentery after food intake by Gasparo Aselli in 1622, and its association with lipid-associated pathologies. However, many questions remain to be answered in order to establish the link between lymphatic function and fat or cholesterol accumulation in tissues. For example, studies should address whether lymphatic dysfunction is associated with obesity and hypercholesterolemia in humans and whether it can influence the course of obesity and clinical features associated with hypercholesterolemia including xanthomas, atherosclerosis and diabetes. For that, methods, particularly imaging modalities, to assess lymphatic function such as cholesterol transport, need to be further improved or developed. Further basic research is also required to identify the mechanisms by which adipocytes may influence lymphatic function and to better characterize the population of macrophages maintaining lymphatic vessel homeostasis. Answering these questions is essential as it may provide new avenues to treat atherosclerosis which is still a leading cause of death in industrialized countries throughout the world despite the great success of statin drugs and obesity, whose prevalence is expected to continue to augment. Therefore, the importance of the lymphatic system in these lipid-related diseases underscores the urgent need to find pharmacological or surgical interventions that can improve lymphatic function which are currently not available. Finally, a better understanding of the implications of lymphatic endothelium in shaping adaptive immune responses particularly during disease is imperative as lymphatic vessels may be a promising target for immunotherapies.
This work was supported by grants from BioMedical Research Council, National Medical Research Council and National Research Foundation to VA.